Which college football coaches are most respected?

I've been thinking about successful college football coaches recently, and I'm curious as to what makes certain ones more liked than others. Is it mainly about their win-loss record, or do other factors like player development and personal integrity play a role? Anyone have any insights?

Respect for college football coaches often comes from a combination of their win-loss record, player development, integrity, as well as their holistic contribution to the university and larger community. While wins and championship titles naturally enhance a coach's reputation, there are several other factors that fans, players, and peers admire.

For example, a coach's ability to cultivate significant player improvement and prepare athletes for future success can be highly respected. This includes not only athletic development but also academic success and personal growth. Coaches who prioritize their players' full collegiate experience, not just their time on the field, often earn a lot of respect.

Moreover, personal integrity is another defining factor. Coaches who respect the rules of the game, exhibit good sportsmanship, and treat others with kindness and respect are often very well-liked, regardless of their win-loss record.

A great example of a respected coach is Tony Dungy. Despite having coached in the NFL and not in college, he is often revered for his strong character, leadership, and commitment to his players' well-being.

In the college ranks, coaches like Nick Saban (Alabama), Dabo Swinney (Clemson), and Danny Gonzales (New Mexico) come to mind. These coaches have experienced significant success on the field, but they also regularly receive appreciation for their focus on players' holistic development and personal integrity. They have proven to be as much educators and mentors as they are strategists and leaders.

In general, it's the coaches who find the balance between success on the field and personal growth off it that end up being the most respected in the long run.