Macalester vs Carleton: Which One Should I Choose?

I've been accepted to both Macalester and Carleton, and I'm having a tough time deciding between the two. Can anyone share their experiences or thoughts on these schools? I'm interested in both academics and overall campus life. Thank you!

Congratulations on your acceptances to both Macalester and Carleton! Choosing between these two colleges can be a difficult decision, as both institutions are reputable and have strong academic programs. I'll try to break down some key differences between the two to help you make a more informed choice.

Location: Macalester is located in St. Paul, Minnesota, offering a more urban feel, while Carleton is in Northfield, a charming small town environment. Proximity to cities like Minneapolis and St. Paul can provide Macalester students with internship and networking opportunities as well as a wider variety of activities. On the other hand, Carleton's campus has a close-knit community, and Northfield is known as a college town, featuring a picturesque downtown area.

Academics: Both schools are well known for their strong focus on liberal arts. However, Carleton has a trimester system, with three 10-week terms, while Macalester has a more traditional semester system. Consider your preferred pace, as the trimester system may affect the intensity of the coursework. Additionally, while both schools offer a wide range of majors, strengths can vary. For example, Carleton is recognized for its strong science and math programs while Macalester is known for its strength in international relations and geography.

Campus Life: Carleton's campus has a reputation for being quirky, with a friendly and inclusive culture - students often describe themselves as ambitious but not aggressively competitive. Macalester also has a welcoming atmosphere with a student population that prioritizes social justice, diversity, and a global perspective, possibly due to its larger percentage of international students. When it comes to extracurriculars, both colleges have numerous clubs and activities, with Carleton having slightly more intramural sports options.

It's crucial to consider what factors are most important to you, such as location, academic culture, and campus life. If possible, visit both campuses or attend virtual events and talk to current students to gain more insight into each school. Ultimately, choose the college that aligns best with your personal preferences and where you feel you'll thrive academically, socially, and personally. Best of luck with your decision!