Compulsory Military Service for High School Dropouts: Opinions?

This might be a controversial topic but interested in your thoughts. Should high school dropouts be required to join the military? What's your take on this issue (both pros and cons) and why?

Speaking from a neutral perspective, it's important to consider both sides in this discussion.

On the positive side, mandatory military service could provide structure and discipline, which may be beneficial for some people who have not found success in traditional school settings. The military also offers apprenticeships and other training programs in many trades and professions, which could equip dropouts with valued job skills.

However, there are various concerns as well. Not all individuals may be fit or suitable for military service for physical, psychological, or ethical reasons. Mandatory service could also infringe on personal freedoms, potentially creating resentment. Additionally, equating a lack of formal education with a need for military discipline may perpetuate harmful stereotypes and stigmas about high school dropouts.

Many dropouts leave school due to fundamental issues like financial instability, family crises, health problems, or learning difficulties. Therefore, other initiatives like improving the quality of education, providing socio-emotional support in school, and offering vocational training or apprenticeships may be more effective in addressing dropout rates. The conversation around the solution for high school dropouts should focus on resolving these root causes.

It's essential to consider compromise measures as well, such as offering voluntary military enlistment or civil service programs to high school dropouts with incentives such as job training, scholarship opportunities, and more.

All in all, it's a complex topic that requires careful thought, and these are just a few points. I'd be interested in hearing other perspectives on this as well.