Current juniors, how are you deciding on which Common App essay prompt to tackle? I'm struggling to pick the one that would best represent me. Does anyone have advice on how to figure out which prompt might help tell my story in a compelling way?
Selecting a Common App essay prompt is certainly a pivotal part of your application, and it's great that you're giving it considerable thought. The best prompt is the one that allows you to share something meaningful and personal about yourself that isn't evident elsewhere in your application. Consider the experiences, insights, or moments that have profoundly impacted your perspective or shaped your character. Reflecting on these can often lead you to the right prompt naturally.
For example, if you have a unique hobby or interest that has influenced your outlook or ambitions, Prompt 1 might be a great choice as it asks you to share your story. Or, if there's been a pivotal moment of failure or setback that you've learned from, Prompt 2 could provide a strong narrative framework. The key is to pick the prompt that feels less like a response to a question and more like an open door to narrate something significant about who you are. Don't force a story to fit a prompt—let your genuine story guide you to the right one.
And don't forget, if none of the prompts feel like the right option, you can always create your own prompt or submit an essay that addresses a different prompt under Prompt 7.
CollegeVine’s Q&A seeks to offer informed perspectives on commonly asked admissions questions. Every answer is refined and validated by our team of admissions experts to ensure it resonates with trusted knowledge in the field.