4 years ago
Admissions Advice

Would it help if I were completely honest with setbacks I've had throughout my high school career?

I am currently a senior in high school. I moved to the states two years ago from Puerto Rico. My freshman year at my old school was quite bad. I had teachers who were indifferent to my success, I didn't have the chance to take APs, and my school hardly offered extracurriculars for artists. It definitely offered none for musicians. When I transferred to a school in Florida as a sophomore, I learned I had many more opportunities to express myself and to pursue my interests. However, sophomore year was hard because I knew nothing about the school and because I was getting used to speaking English over Spanish. Moreover, I knew nobody. The counselor that helped me create my schedule for sophomore year, I feel, was too judgmental of where I came from. He must've thought that my old school in Puerto Rico was way easier than my current one (even though I had taken all honors classes, the most rigorous schedule one could possibly have at that school) since he decided to give me a regulars biology class and no APs. I just feel like I wasted the first two years of high school and that now, I don't have enough experience I could add to my resume to even consider applying to my dream schools, which are all highly competitive schools. I took AP classes last year for the first time (only two). This year, I am taking as many as I can (five), but I know I am far behind my peers in terms of experience and credits earned. I tend to dwell on the past and on things I can't change, so what can I do before January to enhance my resume and increase my eligibility for competitive schools?

Also, as I implied, I am a musician. I have played the piano since I was little and started singing for my school choir last year. I am part of a music ministry group at my school. I also had the chance to finally take a music theory class this year. Since I have the most experience in the music field, would you agree that my best option is to approach my applications from that angle? I also love to write, and I love biology, but I have no experience that will help me prove I'm good at either of those things.

And I know that this sounds like a sob story, but I really need help. Please believe me when I say I hate having to type this. I just want to go to a good college and be happy because high school sucks.

🎉 First post
Let’s welcome @rosekiwi to the community! Remember to be kind, helpful, and supportive in your responses.

Earn karma by helping others:

1 karma for each ⬆️ upvote on your answer, and 20 karma if your answer is marked accepted.

2 answers

Accepted Answer
4 years ago

The simple answer I would say is yes, it's probably best if you're honest about setbacks in your application. What makes the answer a bit more complex is HOW you plan on describing those setbacks. I'll get to that point in a second but I wanted to touch on your concerns about class rigor. If you took all honors classes while in Puerto Rico then the admissions counselor who looks at your application will know that. That's going to come in handy when they look at your application and look at the academic rigor of your time in Florida. I don't think you're going to get impacted too bad by no honors or APs during your sophomore year. I'm not sure how it worked in your school but many times schools won't even offer AP classes to sophomores. Even if your school did I would bet that there were limited ones you could sign up for. In addition, you just moved from Puerto Rico and had to get used to a new language, a new place/school, and make new friends. That's A LOT for someone to handle at once. It's perfectly reasonable, at least in my opinion, and fairly easy to explain why you had slightly easier classes.

You're making up for your AP classes now which is great. I don't know how many APs you could possibly take at your schools but 7 APs seems to be a good number given your circumstances. You mention you're behind your peers in credits earned. Are you referring to credits from AP classes only or credits in general? I ask only because if it's the latter I'm curious if you are you on track to graduate on time? If you'll need an extra semester to graduate I'd try to get a few more APs/Honors classes in. But, if you're set to graduate on time, I wouldn't stress. As you mentioned, this is in the past and there is nothing you can do to change things now. It's not worth stressing over something you can no longer control and that mental energy is better spent elsewhere.

Let me get back to my point about how you present these setbacks in your application. The tone and way you describe these setbacks is going to be extremely important. Why? I'd argue there is a fine line between stating what happened and an admission officer thinking you are taking a "woe is me" attitude. If you do the latter it will not look good for you on your application. I'd be careful how you describe the fact you feel teachers were indifferent to your success while in PR and that you think your counselor in Florida judged your previous school. I'm not saying you can't talk about that but be very careful in how you do it and the words you choose. If you do include that information I would spend minimal time on it (like a sentence max) as you can use the already limited word counts in a better way.

For the last part of your question I'm confused if you're wondering what to include for extracurriculars or if you want to know if music is a good idea to write about for your essay. It sounds like you have the most experience with music so it might make sense to write about that, especially if you can incorporate your experience of moving from PR to FL and the impact that had on how you view music. I do think it's still worth talking about your love for writing and biology too if you can include it on your activities section of the app. Here are some Collegevine articles I think you might find helpful regarding ECs: https://blog.collegevine.com/how-to-improve-your-extracurriculars-junior-and-senior-year/ and https://blog.collegevine.com/your-complete-list-of-extracurricular-activities/ and https://blog.collegevine.com/extracurriculars-you-can-do-at-home/. The first article talks about how to improve your ECs in 12th grade, the second is a list of ECs you can consider, and the 3rd mentions ECs you can do at home.

Hope this helped answer your question! More than happy to answer any follow-up questions you have or clarify anything I said.

4 years ago

I would totally add this in the additional information section of your Common App if that is the method you are using to apply to colleges. I think that explaining why things may not have went so well for you, especially in the beginning of your high school career, would be helpful information for an admissions officer to know when reading your application.

What are your chances of acceptance?
Your chance of acceptance
Duke University
+ add school
Your chancing factors
Unweighted GPA: 3.7
SAT: 720 math
| 800 verbal


Low accuracy (4 of 18 factors)

Community Guidelines

To keep this community safe and supportive:

  1. Be kind and respectful!
  2. Keep posts relevant to college admissions and high school.
  3. Don’t ask “chance-me” questions. Use CollegeVine’s chancing instead!

How karma works